He offers his reflection on the acknowledgements, and the results of his research on whether or not acknowledgments influence examiners–do click on the link to his interesting article.I am beginning to get the notion that acknowledgments humanise the examination process.Tags: Writing A Paper For PublicationSimple Research Paper PowerpointTemplate For A Literature ReviewPros And Cons Essay StructureEssay On Seasonal Affective DisorderLegalizing Weed EssayThematic Essay ConclusionEconomics Extended Essays TopicsResearch Papers In Computer Networking
At times, I am affected when the candidate writes about their struggles – leaving family behind to pursue their dreams, death of loved ones, hardship while doing the Ph D and also the time it took for them to submit as this may reflect financial hardship.
I become extremely sympathetic reading about parents who have to balance the Ph D and care for children during the journey – these struggles speak to the human side of an examiner and I expect other examiners to be the same.
That is, it’s not the acknowledgements they are suspicious of but they are influenced by them and have a biased view on the acknowledgments.
Even though many claim not to be influenced by the acknowledgments, there is anecdotal evidence to suggest that they act differently after reading the acknowledgements.
On the academic level, Mohamed taught me fundamentals of conducting scientific research in the database systems area.
Under his supervision, I learned how to define a research problem, find a solution to it, and finally publish the results.
This became a research quest; I asked myself – are doctoral examiners influenced by the acknowledgments? But does this impact the final outcome of the thesis?
This curiosity led me to research this topic and resulted in a research project surveying 145 doctoral examiners that I describe in this paper.
Conversations with colleagues across the globe suggests that many examiners read the acknowledgments first before reading the thesis – their reasons echoing my own for reading the acknowledgments.
Many say that the acknowledgements provide the context of the candidate and the journey but do not influence their judgement on the assessment of the thesis.